Low Power Variable Optic VS. Red Dot with Magnifier
Primary Arms Staff9/6/2019 5:41 pmwww.primaryarms.com
The Best AR-15 Scope For The Money Might Just Be TWO Scopes
The challenge of balancing speed and accuracy is a huge part of what makes shooting a modern sporting rifle so much fun. Whether you are ringing steel at 600 yards from a Daniel Defense .308 or running through a close quarters tactical drill with an AK-47, the ambition is always the same—achieving the hits you need as quickly as possible. The best upgrades and accessories will help you put your sights on target faster, help you hit the target with greater precision, or help achieve both of those goals simultaneously. There are a ton of choices out there, so this battle is focused on two of the most popular configurations for the AR-15 carbine—the low power variable optic (LPVO) versus the red dot and magnifier combo.
A quality optic tops the list of the best AR-15 mods for boosting both speed and accuracy. For decades every AR-15 had fixed iron sights and that’s what almost everybody used. Carry handle optics were considered an exotic luxury seen only with elite special forces units and the occasional oddball civilian shooter. Today it is rare to see anyone shooting an AR with iron sights only unless they are a retro builder or just starting out with a brand-new rifle. Chat with one of these shooters at the range and they will usually tell you all about which scope they plan on buying! The hot question now isn’t whether AR-15 scopes are a good idea, but which configuration is the best rifle scope for the money.
BACK IN BLACK – LOW POWER VARIABLE SCOPES
Low power variable optics use an etched reticle that your eye sees as a black shape contrasted against the field of view. In more advanced LPVOs, the reticle may be illuminated by battery power, fiber optics, or some other light source. Unlike the red dot’s reflected light projection reticle, the LPVO’s etched reticle is always present regardless of battery status, although without illumination they can be difficult to use in low light conditions or at night. The science behind etched reticle optics also means LPVOs must cope with visual limitations that just aren’t a factor with red dots. For example, “eye relief” defines the distance between the ocular lens at the rear of the scope and the ideal placement of your eye. If a LPVO scope has an eye relief of 3.5 inches, placing your eye just 1 inch behind the lens results in an unusable sight picture. Placing your eye 5 inches behind the lens also results in, you guessed it, no sight picture. “Exit pupil” is the diameter of the shaft of light coming out of the ocular lens, which your eye must line up with to see that etched reticle correctly and take an accurate shot. Move your head too much up or down, side to side, and you’ll see the reticle distort with odd crescent-shaped shadows appearing in the sight picture just before the view goes completely black. The overall space where your eye can acquire the reticle correctly, allowing you to take an accurate shot, is called the “eye box”. Eye box is difficult to quantify. No manufacturer can put a number on it, but for fast shooting up close a good eye box is absolutely essential in a LPVO. Exit pupil, and therefore eye box, is dependent on the size of the front or objective lens compared to the magnification setting of the scope. At 1x the eye box on a quality LPVO will be so large and forgiving that it is possible to shoot with both eyes open like a red dot, and almost as quickly. At higher magnifications the eye box will get smaller, your point of aim will seem much more sensitive, and it will take more time to aim your rifle.
The greatest advantage of the low power variable optic is the “variable” part. Shooting up close using both eyes open with wide view of 1x magnification is a great start, but the magic happens with the ability to crank up magnification until more distant targets seem 4, 6, or even 8 times closer than they are. When combined with smart reticles like the Primary Arms Advanced Combined Sighting System, the LPVO offers precision at medium ranges that no red dot sight can match. ACSS combines bullet drop compensation, range estimation, wind holds, and moving target leads all into the reticle. Once it is sighted in correctly for your ammunition type and muzzle velocity, you never have to do math or count windage and elevation clicks. The reticle provides visual cues to help you aim using the proper holdover in a huge variety of shooting situations. If your target is a steel plate or a coyote at an unknown distance between 300 and 500 yards, and wind is pushing left to right at 10 mph, a 1-6x LPVO with an ACSS reticle will get you on target with certainty. Comparatively, a 2 MOA red dot gives you no help at all in determining the correct aiming point. If you simply place the dot on the target, you are guaranteed to miss, even if using a magnifier. The red dot is generally the wrong tool for complex shooting situations at ranges beyond 100 yards. One notable exception is the Holosun HS503G – ACSS CQB, featuring a unique ACSS reticle with a center chevron and multiple bullet drop compensation dots. The Holosun ACSS definitely offers a more intelligent approach to long distance red dot shooting, but it is an exception, not the rule.
A low power variable optic is a larger, bulkier choice than even a full size red dot. They take up the entire Picatinny rail section on an AR-15 or AR-308 and add over a pound of weight of your carbine along with the necessary mount. The hit to your wallet increases as well. Quality red dots can be had for under $100 and even the most expensive Aimpoint red dot is priced under $1000. You’ll need close to $300 for a quality 1-6x LPVO, and prices get more expensive quickly. Premium options like the Vortex Razor HD Gen II 1-6x cost $1300-1500, and top of the line units from Schmidt & Bender can approach $4,000!
No matter how much money you spend, it is generally agreed that a LPVO set to 1x magnification will not be as fast, nor as forgiving, as a red dot for close quarters shooting. With careful scope setup and a lot of practice, the difference can be minimized, but it is still there. Reticle illumination is never quite as bright as with a red dot, although there are some LPVOs out there that get pretty close, if you are willing to spend more money. However, because of the differences in technology involved, battery life is no comparison at all. There are several micro red dots available with 50,000 hour battery life for as little as $150 with a lifetime warranty, but a 50,000 hour battery life LPVO does not yet exist at any price.
Here are how the pros and cons stack up for the low power variable optic.
- Superior magnification flexibility
- Etched reticle always present even with dead battery
- More advanced/complex reticles possible
- Superior reticle sharpness for shooters with astigmatism
- Greatly improved accuracy especially past 100 yards
- Size and weight penalty vs. red dot alone
- Can easily cost more than comparable red dot + magnifier setup
- Not as fast to acquire as a red dot, even at 1x with both eyes open
- Less flexible on mounting locations due to eye box demands
- Reticle illumination not as bright as red dots
- Illumination battery life not even close to red dots
SEEING RED – THE RED DOT SCOPE
In 1975 a group of American Special Forces prepared for a night raid to rescue American prisoners of war in North Vietnam. Spray-and-pray with iron sights wasn’t going to cut it for a rescue mission in the dark with American lives on the line. The Son Tay Raiders attached Armson “Singlepoint” occluded optic gunsights to their rifles, creating the concept of the red dot equipped AR-15 before true red dot scopes were even invented. Fast forward more than 40 years and red dots are now the most popular AR-15 tactical optics for fast shooting at closer ranges. The red dot is king of sight acquisition speed because unlike a traditional rifle scope, it has no eye relief, exit pupil or eye box. The dot you see when looking through the sight is not projected forward onto the target like a laser, but bounced off a curved piece of glass and reflected back towards your eye. The limit of your sight picture is the field of view that you see through the sight’s “window”. If you can see the dot at all, even in just a fraction of the scope’s field of view, you can use the dot to take a decently accurate shot, if you must. Looking at a traditional scope from the same angle, you would be unable to get any sight picture at all.
But this doesn’t mean red dots are flawless and have no disadvantages. It’s true that modern red dots have incredible battery life, often measured in years. But if the battery does unexpectedly fail, the red dot loses its sight picture entirely, leaving you with no aiming point at all unless you have back up iron sights to deploy. Many shooters with astigmatism or other eye issues don’t see the dot clearly, instead seeing a comet or squiggly lines. Taking an accurate shot with such an undefined point of aim can be difficult or impossible. Some shooters have better luck seeing red dot sights that use holographic weapons sight technology. EOTech and Vortex holographic sights create the reticle by using a laser diode and collimating reflector rather than an LED emitter. While the overall effect looks a lot like a traditional red dot, the technology used to deliver it is different.
Here are the pros and cons of current technology red dot optics.
RED DOT PROS
- Best possible sight picture acquisition speed
- Both eyes open shooting is easy for maximum peripheral vision
- Intense reticle brightness grabs the eye instantly even in bright sunlight
- Unsurpassed battery life
- Excellent value per dollar, whether budget red dot or top-of-the-line
- Light weight, minimal bulk
RED DOT CONS
- No battery means no sight picture
- No magnification to aid accuracy or target identification
- Eyes with astigmatism or other medical issues struggle with the dot’s appearance
- Advanced reticle features are normally not present or difficult to utilize
LEVEL UP – RED DOT MAGNIFIERS
The red dot’s simplicity and lack of magnification are its biggest strengths in fast close quarters shooting. Beyond 100 yards, these strengths become the red dot’s greatest weakness. There are two types of red dot magnifiers which can add some magnification to help the red dot step its game up. Screw-in style magnifiers such as the Lucid HD7 magnifier attach an additional set of lenses behind the red dot scope by directly threading into the scope body. Most screw-in magnifiers provide 2x magnification and are normally left screwed into the red dot at all times, as hurried attempts to attach and detach them will likely result in stripped threads and misaligned lenses. More commonly, the magnifier is a separate stand-alone optic that is placed behind the red dot in its own mount. Although a fixed mount such as simple 30mm scope ring can be used to place the magnifier, doing this results in the same disadvantage as the screw-in design—eye relief and eye box limitations of the magnifier lenses (similar to the LPVO) now apply to the red dot as well, so the red dot loses its close quarters speed more or less permanently (until the magnifier is dismounted from the rifle entirely). The best mount for a red dot magnifier is a flip-to side configuration. These mounts place the magnifier behind the red dot for longer range shots yet allow you to instantly flip the magnifier out of your field of view when desired. 3x or 6x magnification when needed, without subtracting any of the red dot’s advantages when flipped out of the way.
However adding a magnifier adds the disadvantages of traditional optics. Magnifiers have eye relief and eye box, just like LPVOs. Say goodbye to the red dot’s sight acquisition speed, and goodbye to co-witnessing iron sights as well. While 3x magnifiers can offer a pretty forgiving eye box, their larger 6x cousins can be picky to work with—overall slower to acquire than a comparable LPVO with its magnification set to 6x. You are also forced to choose just one possible magnification-- a screw-in 2x, a 3x, OR a 6x. There is no way to smoothly transition your magnification from 1x through 6x behind a red dot, and while quality 1-8x LPVOs are an excellent value, I’m unaware of any 8x magnifier at any price. If you have aspirations of taking quality shots at 400-600 yards, even using the advanced Holosun ACSS red dot reticle in combination with a 6x magnifier will be much more difficult than just cranking up a 1-6x or 1-8x LPVO to full magnification.
Flipping the magnifier out of the way also causes some practical issues that aren’t an issue with the LPVO. A big advantage of shooting both eyes open with the red dot sight is that you don’t lose any peripheral vision. Having a second scope hanging off the side of the rifle just inches in front of your face blocks a surprising amount of that vision. The magnifier also tends to snag on things, generally get in your way, and the flip-to-side mounts are complex and can be prone to breakage with rough handling.
The magnifier also magnifies your perception of the red dot along with the rest of the field of view. While the magnification certainly helps with accuracy, that help is limited by the size of the red dot. At 100 yards you will clearly be able to see that a 2 MOA dot covers two inches of target, and a 6 MOA dot covers six inches of target. At 200 yards the 6 MOA dot will appear to be about 12 inches wide. That’s not optimal when compared to the precise reticles available in LPVOs. It is important to realize that the dot size isn’t actually changing—the magnifier just helps you see that dot size better than you can at 1x magnification. One method of addressing this issue is to select a red dot with a chevron aiming point instead of a dot, like the Holosun ACSS. The chevron tip is an infinitely small aiming point that never obscures the target, so that’s an improvement over a simple dot. The Holosun ACSS pairs wonderfully with a magnifier, but adding magnification to the reflected LED reticle still doesn’t give you the LPVO’s etched reticle sharpness.
Stand alone magnifiers start affordably near the $100 mark, with premium models approaching $600. But you must also purchase that flip-to-side mount, so there’s a hidden cost lurking there. By the time you add the magnifier and its mount to the cost of your red dot and its mount, you are approaching the same cost, bulk, and weight as buying a comparable LPVO setup.
Here are the pros and cons of the red dot magnifier.
- Adds magnification to red dot for better accuracy and target identification
- Does not affect red dot’s benefits when flipped out of the way (dependent on mount type)
- Does not affect zero—can be easily moved from rifle to rifle
- Limited field of view and eyebox, like a fixed power scope
- Can only add one level of magnification
- Adds complexity, weight and bulk
- Flip-to-side type: second optics mount must be purchased
- Flip-to-side type: makes rifle effectively wider when not in use
- Exposes truth of dot size relative to target
HEAD TO HEAD—BEST APPLICATIONS FOR EACH CONFIGURATION
Each of these configurations is fast and flexible. When choosing between them, it can be helpful to define your primary shooting objectives versus your secondary shooting objectives, and select the optics choice that boosts performance most in your primary category. For example, if your primary objective is close quarters speed shooting, and accuracy at longer distances is secondary, you might decide that the red dot + magnifier fits your needs best. If your primary objective is a balance of speed and accuracy at all ranges from 35 feet to 350 yards, then the low power variable optic might suit your shooting style best.
Carefully consider the type of shooting you intend to do with your AR-15. If you plan on tactical shooting around barricades or vehicles, shooting from unusual and stressful positions, the ability to get a red dot sight picture with an imperfect cheek weld and poor eye alignment becomes a huge advantage. If you plan on doing competitions where you might get just one chance at a “bonus” steel target 300 yards away, the LPVO is the smarter option.
There are also special circumstances where certain shooters or rifle setups can’t take advantage of one system’s benefits in some way. For example, a shooter with astigmatism who has trouble seeing red dots may decide that their eyesight rules out using a red dot under any circumstances, pushing them to the LPVO’s etched reticle for all types of shooting. A short-barreled rifle or AR-15 pistol build will have greatly reduced terminal effect at longer ranges due to reduced muzzle velocity, making longer range shooting impractical. The altered bullet trajectory from a shorter rifle barrel also makes bullet drop compensation reticles incompatible, negating what would normally be an advantage for the LPVO. The best scope choice should match up the rifle’s configuration, so in this case a red dot is the right call.
For some folks the decision comes down to the smaller details. Some red dot shooters hate carrying spare batteries and want the reassurance of incredibly long battery life, or they demand a much brighter reticle than LPVOs can provide. Some LPVO shooters don’t want to settle for a single magnified setting of 3x or 6x, demanding the ability to seamlessly access all magnifications using a single optic. If one of these distinctions reaches out and grabs you, trust your instincts and run with it—you aren’t wrong!
Here are some overall strategy recommendations when making your decision.
USE A RED DOT + MAGNIFIER WHEN:
- Ultimate speed up close is most important and targets beyond 200 yards are not a possibility at all
- You are tactical shooting indoors or around vehicles, where eye position won’t be ideal
- Using unusual barrel lengths or calibers where a BDC reticle is not available
- You only desire two magnifications, 1x and 3x (or rarely 6x)
- You demand daylight bright illumination
- You want to leave illumination always on for years at a time
USE A LOW POWER VARIABLE OPTIC WHEN:
- You anticipate engaging targets as distances over 200 yards
- You can take a bit more time at 1x and want more precision past 100 yards
- You can get a consistent sight picture at all times while shooting
- Your caliber and barrel length match up well with a smart BDC reticle system
- Astigmatism gives you trouble with seeing red dots
- You envision using multiple magnifications depending on situation
- Daylight bright illumination not as important as a permanent etched reticle
- You don’t mind swapping batteries more often if using bright illumination settings
If you are researching which optic is right for your next build and you just can’t make up your mind, feel free to call 713-344-9600 or email email@example.com. Our dedicated customer service team here in Houston, Texas is standing by to help you get a great deal on your perfect optics setup!